The Fulton Store

In 2019, Sarah and her fiance, Eric took over the Fulton Store and created a Yelp!, Travelocity popular destination for foodies, and locals alike. Part convenience store, two parts breakfast and lunch restaurant, with a steady parade of pizza carryout at dinner time. The Fulton Store is a famous breakfast bakery paradise for the three recipes Eric and Sarah inherited from the previous owners, their rolls:  cinnamon, raspberry or blueberry cream cheese filled ones. And another well-known, homemade dish locals delight in is the take-home casseroles. "It kind of started by accident. One of our customers asked us we could make something (casserole) like that, then we thought maybe we could to do these and freeze them for to go," says Sarah. Customers can choose from a variety of casseroles from Tator tot, and lasagna, to chicken parmesan, chicken pot pie, Mexican quesadilla, and southwest themed version with kilbassa, goulash or  beef stroganoff.  Sarah's favorite is the lasagna casserole. She really likes their meat sauce, "I take home the sauce if their is leftover and make it with spaghetti."

The Fulton General Store

9413 N Co Rd H, Edgerton, WI

Phone:(608) 884-0131

Two Brothers Downtown Pub and Grill

According to the great reviews on Travelocity and Yelp! this restaurant has the Best Friday night fish fry in the area. They serve the walleye filet whole, the batter is light and crispy, not greasy at all. I would like to see a larger variety of fish on their menu, like perch and bluegill, but after being served the best walleye I've ever had, ILive band be a large patio area,  filet kabobs, also have a wide range of sandwiches, burgers and wraps if you are on the road and just need to stop for a bite. You definitely won't be disappointed. lack and bleu salad
Steak tacos, Fish tacos, Rib eye steak sandwich
Chicken wild rice soup, Great homemade soups and the best humongous salads you'll ever see. My husband loved the spareribs. Pizza night Monday and Fish Fry on Fridays.  Nashville Chicken Sandwich!!  Nashville Hot Chicken Sliders, cheese curds. Awesome breading, huge breast deep fried to juicy perfection with slaw and a sweet/spicy sauce. fish, pizza, ribs, salads, and other classic bar food and drinks.  Wednesday Walleye.

The Brooklyn Burger, Lake perch is good.

116 W Fulton St, Edgerton, WI 53534-1839

Phone (608) 884 3088

Café on Main

Greek Skillet with gyro meat, Florentine omelette with fresh spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes, and cheese



Address: 118 Merchant Row
Milton, WI 53563
Phone: (608)-868-2966

Lakehouse Inn

Perched on a hill overlooking Lake Koshkonong the Lakehouse Inn is the essence of a Wisconsin Supper Club. Inside this historic Italianate building that once housed the Koshkonong Hotel is the Friday Fish Fry legacy of 50 years. The popularity of this venue demands the use of an online reservation system like Resy.

1612 E Hotel Dr, Edgerton, WI 53534

Phone

(608) 884 0116

https://benedettisclub51.wordpress.com/menu/

The Henry Street Social

Like a number of our recommended restaurants in Edgerton, the Henry Street Social is located in one of the town's beautifully restored historic buildings downtown.

Address: 110 N Henry St, Edgerton, WI 53534

Phone (608) 449-0218

For reservations call:   (608) -362-8577
http://www.butterflyclub.us/

The Campbell Boys

Candy, ice cream and sandwiches all in one historic building in downtown Edgerton. Two local brothers found their calling with very unique twists on more commonplace sandwiches with fresh bread and Boar's Head meats. Take for example, the with fig paste. Homemade vegetable beef soup. And check out the retro candy offerings around the front counter, amazing array of classics that the mother of the two brothers says was brought back to life thanks to an enterprising company buying the brands and their time tested sweet recipes. And any time of year is appropriate for ice cream from local favorite Chocolate Shoppe.

115 N. Henry Street, Edgerton
Phone: (608) 883-6988

https://www.duckinndelavan.com/

The Red Baron



Looking for delicious pizza, a lively environment and an overall great place to hangout, grab a drink and eat? Then make Red Baron your destination of choice.

Filled with a variety of taps, spirits and a vast selection of other brews, there is little chance that anyone will leave Red Baron with an unquenched thirst.

With a focus on creating unique and delicious handmade pizzas, Red Baron uses only the freshest ingredients to curate a tasting experience like no other.

Live Music

Featuring an indoor stage along with an outdoor patio, Red Baron has a full list of live bands and music acts that can be enjoyed all year long.

Address: 24 W Fulton St, Edgerton, WI 53534
Phone:   (608)-364-4615

http://

Buckhorn Supper Club

Is there a more apt location for a supper club then shoreside by a lake? If there ever was a Southern Wisconsin restaurant with that true look and feel of a Northwoods' supper club the Buckhorn on the shores of Lake Koshkonong would have to be it. Enjoy great food classics like prime rib and the traditional Friday Fish Fry too.

Please note: 11802 N Charley Bluff Road in the winter months is a destination for ice fishing. The road might be a bit narrowed by the abundance of angler pickup trucks and SUVs.

Address: 11802 N Charley Bluff Rd, Milton, WI 53563
Phone: (608)-868-2653
https://buckhornsupperclub.com/about

Helgesen's Harpos

Established in 2006 and located on the outskirts of Janesville, Helgesen's Harpos is a relative newcomer on the scene but the food is all classic supper club fare. Check out the frog legs and mash potatoes for starters.

Address: 5201 State Road 11
Janesville, WI 53548
Phone: (608)-752-8886

http://helgesensharpos.com/

 Kavanaugh's Esquire Club

On Madison's northside this long time supper club has the outward appearance of a family-style restaurant but Kavanaugh's serves up traditional classics like steak and seafood with sides like any true supper club.

Address: 1025 N. Sherman Avenue
Madison, WI 53704
Phone: (608) -249-0193

http://kavanaughsesquire.club/

Toby’s Supper Club

Though adjacent to Stoughton Road, Toby's is a bit of a challenge to get to. If you go on a Friday night and arrive after rush hour quickly review the large parking lot before committing to an evening of eating. Even if the lot is not full, it may already be jammed to the rafters with hungry and thirsty patrons especially on a Friday night. Toby's has lots of regulars. Expect to wait at the bar before you begin your own culinary adventure. At Toby's every meal begins with the relish tray. What's behind the popularity? The food, filet mignon, chicken, prime rib, walleye (et al) has a lot to do with that.

3717 S Dutch Mill Rd
Madison, WI 53718
Phone: (608)-222-6913

http://www.tobyssupperclub.com/Home.html